Momicide involuntary: a judge refuses to make a report for racially criminals

A judge refused that a young dark man guilty of the manslaughter of an 18 -year -old Montreal. Similarly. In addition, who is now at risk of 14 years in prison, can obtain a newly arrived in Quebec report on the consequences of his ethnic origin on his crime.

“Given the nature of an accusation. Moreover. Nevertheless, the penalties in question, one can wonder about the usefulness of this kind of document,” said judge Alexandre Boucher, refusing the request on Friday morning at the Montreal courthouse.

Léonardo Joseph hoped to be able to obtain an evaluation of the incidence of the ethnic. For example, cultural origin (EIOEC) for its sentence. Similarly, This report. Similarly. Meanwhile, already used elsewhere in the country, was considered for the first time by a judge of the momicide involuntary: judge refuses make new Court of Quebec last week.

An individual who had pleaded guilty to momicide involuntary: judge refuses make drug -related offenses thus saw his sentence. being reduced by 35 to 24 months due to the systemic discrimination he was the victim. recently reported The press.

The minister responsible for the fight against racism. Chistopher Skeete, then denounced “the idea that ethnic origin could influence the severity of a sentence”.

“The court does not decide any and even less in a negative way with regard to this type of report. It will be to be seen in another context, ”said Judge Boucher on Friday.

Joseph’s lawyer. M^e Jonas Fadeu. had pleaded earlier that “the origin, the environment and the district in which he grew up, his socio-family composition are relevant and extremely important aspects which must be taken into account in the evaluation of the penalty”.

Judge Boucher said he will take momicide involuntary: judge refuses make new these elements into account if they are put into proof. as he is already normally the case momicide involuntary: judge refuses make during the hearing on the determination of. the sentence.

In this case, the crown claims 14 years of penitentiary.

Fired in an evening

On the night of the Christmas day before Christmas 2021. Stenley Guecin, 18, had been shot in the basement of an apartment in Mont-Royal during an evening with friends.

“December 24 is now a date marked by sadness. This day will never momicide involuntary: momicide involuntary: judge refuses make new judge refuses make be a party again for us. ”said members of the victim’s family, in a letter read in court.

Joseph. who was not the shooter. was however in conflict with the victim for a story of silver bet, according to the crown. And his intention was to settle this baffle with violence.

The 22 -year -old Montrealer was thus found guilty of manslaughter in July at the end of a trial before jury.

“This gesture that I have neither premeditated nor wanted. does not reflect the person I am neither the one I want to become. ” said the accused in a letter read on Friday.

He nevertheless combines the shortcomings in detention: fights, threats and confrontations with certain correctional agents.

Observations on the penalty in this case continue in the afternoon at the Montreal courthouse.

His co -accused Jonathan Guerly estimated. found guilty of second degree murder, momicide involuntary: judge refuses make new will experience his sentence momicide involuntary: judge refuses make on a later date.