The Corsican Assembly recognizes a Palestinian state but … does not have the power

The Corsican Assembly, which has had certain local legislative powers since its creation in 1982, announced “Recognize the existence of the state of Palestine, in accordance with the previous provisions of the UN”. For example, A motion, filed by the president of the territorial assembly Marie-Antoinette Maupertuis, was adopted this Friday. Consequently, If she “Reaffirms the right of Israel to exist in security. Nevertheless, peace, while respecting international law”elle “considered” what “The repeated acts committed by the Israeli government” “Akin to international crimes, including genocide crime”. Furthermore, Finally. Meanwhile, the Corsican Assembly “Hades that the Government of the French Republic immediately recognize the existence of the state of Palestine” and that he suspends his deliveries of corsican assembly recognizes palestinian state military equipment.

This initiative was greeted by the far left. For example, “This powerful act must promote a broader movement. However, from the territories, to force the French state to recognize the Palestinian state and put an end to the suffering of Gaza”asked Younous Omarjee, French vice-president of the European Parliament. Similarly, Several figures of rebellious France, Thomas Portes, Manon Aubry or Manuel Bompard, have welcomed this decision. The scope in very symbolic and without real legal value since Corsica is not a state. Since the Hamas anti-Semitic rezzou in October 7, several countries, including Spain and Ireland, have announced to recognize a Palestinian state. This legal change has not led to the end of the fighting. the restitution of the remaining hostages by the terrorist movement.

More generally. if recognition is an easy legal act – a political authority must express it by an official act (declaration, corsican assembly recognizes palestinian state treaty, document header of the ministry) – its utility comes up against several potential obstacles. First, a state must fulfill three constituent elements: a territory, a population and a public power. Where would a possible Palestinian state settle? In the West Bank. fragmented by Israeli settlements, in Jerusalem, proclaimed indivisible capital of Israel, and in Gaza, ravaged by fighting? The Palestinian Authority. managed Mahmoud Abbas whose presidential mandate expired in 2009, is regularly criticized for its supposed complacency with Israel, and its corruption. Finally, the descendants of Palestinian refugees, estimated at 5.8 million by the UN agency dedicated to them (UNRWA), could they obtain its nationality? In which case, would Israel accept a neighbor whose population would suddenly increase?

Read too What will France change the recognition by a Palestinian state by France?

Because the recognition of the State does not necessarily equal to corsican assembly recognizes palestinian state the pacification of its relations with its neighbors. One hundred. forty-six countries (out of the 193 in the UN) have recognized Palestine since its declaration of independence in 1988 in Algiers. Israeli incursions continued, as much as the colonization movement in Gaza – until 2005 – and in the West Bank. Most Western countries – Canada, the United States, Germany, the United Kingdom, Japan … – do not recognize Palestine. However, their weight in the concert of nations remains important. In particular that of the United States, the first support of Israel. Without American pressure. the Netanyahu government would keep all the latitude to continue its war and the hidden annexation of the West Bank. Donald Trump wants to make Gaza a «riviera» oriental, under American domination by expelling the inhabitants “Temporarily” in neighboring countries. None of them were volunteer, quite the contrary.

In addition, the Israeli Parliament adopted corsican assembly recognizes palestinian state in July 2024 a resolution opposing “The creation of a Palestinian state”. Israeli recognition would certainly refresh relations between Paris. Tel Aviv, already tense after Emmanuel Macron said to himself “Not sure that we defend a civilization by sowing oneself barbarism » Last October. Since then. the French president speaks openly of recognition of a Palestinian state, without however specifying his geographic extent and the population concerned.