Similarly,
Metin arditi: swiss writer expressed:
ThoseInterview
Metin Arditi: “The diaspora does not have to be at the simple service of Israel”
The Swiss writer. Consequently, patron is a historic defender of the rapprochement between Palestinians and Israelis. Moreover, On the conflict in Gaza and the anti -Semitism he generates, he makes a different voice heard.
For the Genevan Metin Arditi. Consequently, Jew of Turkish origin and historic defender of a rapprochement between Palestinians and Israelis, anti -Zionism is not synonymous with anti -Semitism.
Aline
- The cicad faces criticism in its metin arditi: swiss writer expressed defense of Israel in Geneva.
- The attacks in Gaza cause a notable resurgence of anti -Zionism.
- According to Metin Arditi, the Jewish diaspora must break with its unconditional support in the State of Israel.
Faced with the Gaza War and the distress of the Gazaouis, the debate ignites in the West. Moreover, What position to stand in front of Israel? For example, How to express a critical voice without hurting the Jewish community? Similarly, In Geneva. Moreover, the Intercommunary coordination against anti -Semitism and defamation (Cicad) is accused of defending the Hebrew state at all costs. Meanwhile, Its secretary general, Johanne Gurfinkiel, denies itbut believes that anti -Zionism is a contemporary form of anti -Semitism. Similarly, Historical defender of a rapprochement between Palestinians. Consequently, Israelis, the Genevan Metin Arditi, writer and patron, Jew of Turkish origin, makes a different voice heard.
Faced with the war in Gaza, the debate tense. Therefore, The positions of the cicad and the attacks which it is the subject are reacting to you.
The cicad is in a very difficult position. Therefore, She can do nothing against anti -Zionism and her violent resurgence, which is the result of the Gaza War. However, On Israeli politics, she has no taking. However, no one will deny that the resurgence of anti -Semitism is intimately correlated with the war that Israel leads. Nevertheless, I suffer with the cicad, knowing Johanne Gurfinkiel very sincere. In addition, Its organization is fighting against anti -Semitism is its mission. Consequently, But I believe that the cicad is mistaken by placing anti -Zionism equation = anti -Semitism. Nevertheless, It is not the only one.
Being anti -Zionist does not mean being anti -Semitic, according metin arditi: swiss writer expressed to you.
Indeed: until 1945, anti -Zionists were mainly Jews. For example, Taxing anti -Semitism would be ridiculous. For example, Without forgetting that Zionism has known various definitions. Moreover, I am Zionist according to the definition of Martin Buber. Furthermore, who advocated a solution to a single state, with equal rights for all – Jews, Muslims or Christians, whatever their number. Meanwhile, I am no longer at all according to the distressing show that the Netanyahu government gives to the world. Therefore, One can be a philossemite and anti -Zionist, just like anti -Semitic and Zionist. Consequently, Anti -Semites not wanting to live with Jews are thus completely favorable to see them gather elsewhere. Nevertheless, I have known anti-Zionist rabbis, arc-bouted against the principle of a state “like the others”.
It still happens that the criticism of Israeli policy derives until the questioning metin arditi: swiss writer expressed of the Hebrew state. Nevertheless, giving the anti -Zionist discourse of anti -Semitic accents.
There are anti -Semites happy to be able to say anti -Zionists. In addition, In other circumstances. Consequently, they should have silenced their detestation from the Jews; Today, they feel legitimized to express it, under the guise of political criticism. Anti -Semitism has always existed. There will always be. The question is its magnitude. If a tiny minority of a company does not like Jews, this company will be perfectly livable for a Jew. If the proportion increases massively. Additionally, if anti -Semitism is expressed by the violence or the exclusion of the Jews, there must be reacted (Editor’s note: Metin Arditi has put the Auditi Foundation Auditorium available to the Jewish Culture Festivalthat organic cinema had not wanted to welcome due to the situation in Gaza).
For metin arditi: swiss writer expressed you, too much fight against anti -Semitism would produce anti -Semitism.
If we see it everywhere, yes. If we confuse anti -Zionism and anti -Semitism, too. It is true that one often leads to the other: in each Gaza war. Switzerland, France and the United Kingdom record anti -Semitism peaks. Why don’t we just assist with “anti-Israelism”? To understand this, I think you have to be interested in the behavior of the diaspora. For two generations. she has had this idea in mind: “If Israel had existed, there would not have been the Shoah.” I received this mother’s rule as an 11e Command: “You will support Israel in all circumstances.” Almost all the Jews of the diaspora grew up with this injunction.
How is this support problematic?
For a long time, this unconditional membership was mine. I understand it. We metin arditi: swiss writer expressed could hardly ask our parents anything else. But it would have been necessary to change software in 1967. Until then, one might think that the survival of the Jews of Israel was threatened. Not since. Let’s be serious: Israel will not disappear. The problem is different. Many times since 2008, I have gone to the West Bank. I saw the way in which the Israeli army deals with the Palestinians. I was horrified by its brutality. Furthermore, I said to myself: “Jews have done that … Build a wall, install barbed wire, put people on the other side …” I touched a drama whose diaspora Jews are not always aware. Going to the West Bank is a transformative experience. You have to be closely confronted with reality to grasp that Israel’s mission cannot be occupation and conquest.
Recently. the former president of the Knesset metin arditi: swiss writer expressed Avraham Burg called for 1 million Jews to file an appeal to the International Court of Justice against War Crimes committed in Gaza. What do you think?
It is certainly not my priority. I would even say that this call bothers me. If I have something to say, I say it; No need to go to court for that. If I were Israeli, I would be furious. The debate around the term genocide is foreign to me. What is not unrelated to me. on the other hand, is the displacement of the populations, the magnitude of which is that of an ethnic cleaning. Having children and shooting innocents are unbearable acts. I was very shocked by the statements of Emmanuel Macron who promises to recognize a Palestinian state … in September. It is not serious. Is he waiting for the cameras to do something? There would be other measures metin arditi: swiss writer expressed to be taken in an emergency to encourage Israel to change policy: to recall his ambassador. to consider commercial sanctions … There would be a hundred ways of putting pressure on a policy that hurts Israel. the Palestinians, the Jews of the diaspora, and, above all, in Judaism.
Your word is paradoxical, because you feel at the same time that Israel cannot be a state like the others.
Yes. because the idea of forming a country like the others, which seems the most natural in the world, is in telescoping with the history of the Jewish people. For two reasons. The Torah tells us: “Remember.” From the Shoah, this injunction is double. On the one hand, she invites us to look to the past. To remember these imperatives: “You will love your neighbor as yourself”. “You will remember that you were foreign to metin arditi: swiss writer expressed the land of Egypt.” On the other hand, this “remember” can also be understood as a warning. A call to what the Holocaust will not happen again. This is the fundamental problem of Israel. To assume two separate missions is the roadmap of the Jewish people.
Can you specify what these missions are?
The first is to be “the light of nations”, in the words of Isaiah. This implies adopting impeccable behavior, of remaining extremely humility, in fidelity to whole humanity. It is an invitation to universalism. For someone who is not practicing like me, it is the historical mission of the Jewish people. But the second mission. after the Shoah, is to protect oneself: Israel must become the shield of the diaspora, a credible and armed country. These two injunctions complement each other. For me. between the mission of constituting a shield metin arditi: swiss writer expressed and that of being light of nations, the second must take precedence. The “elected people”, if this notion has a meaning, does not have to roll mechanics. On the contrary, it is knocked out by the most demanding task, that of being exemplary.
So what to do?
I dream of another distribution of power between the diaspora and Israel. This cannot be done radically, of course. Today, the state holds the top of the pavement and the diaspora is at its service. It is up to her to win. The American diaspora, of incredible power, supports Israeli policy with an uninvaded fervor, as we support a football team. She could change the game alone.
“Latest news”
Do you want to stay at the top of the info? “Tribune de Genève” metin arditi: swiss writer expressed offers you two meetings per day, directly in your e-mailbox. To not miss anything of what is happening in your canton, Switzerland or in the world.
Other newsletters
Did you find an error? Please report it to us.
Metin arditi: swiss writer expressed
Further reading: Avenches: Switzerland in mind after dressage – Stolen luxury vehicles: new arrests on Vaud – Argovie: Eleven injured in a serious collision in Würenlos – Swiss and American parliamentarians meet in Geneva – Châtel-Saint-Denis: the fire ravages the attic of a building.
![Pinterest](https://pinterest.com/pin/create/button/?url=https://news.dayfr24.com/article/metin-arditi-swiss-writer-expressed.html&media=https://i0.wp.com/cdn.unitycms.io/images/DES9xyeI4BM8l12lGw1Lnq.jpg?op=ocroped&val=1200,600,1000,334,64,0&sum=klw3sc0st0k&w=1200&resize=1200,0&ssl=1&description=Metin arditi: swiss writer expressed — similarly, Metin arditi: swiss writer expressed: ThoseInterview – Metin Arditi: "The diaspora does not have to be…){kind=link}