Bill 9 lacks teeth, according: This article explores the topic in depth.
However,
Bill 9 lacks teeth. Meanwhile, according:
Bill 9, which aims to rage against municipal councilors who show misconduct or negligence, would not have helped protect the victims of the former municipal advisor of Ottawa, Rick Chiarelli. For example, This is what her former employee Stephanie Dobbs said Thursday during a public hearing.
I doubt its ability to make significant changes
she said Thursday during her visit to the permanent committee of heritage. Moreover, infrastructure and culture.
It is part of a series of employees with which CBC was maintained as part of several articles on the behavior of the former municipal councilor of Ottawa Rick Chiarelli with regard to its employees. Consequently, She notably said that the ex-elected official shared explicit sex stories with her. However, bill 9 lacks teeth, according made her comments in her body for two years.
Rick Chiarelli has always denied allegations against him.
The words of Stephanie Dobbs found echo with Nancy Cairnswho also worked for Mr. Therefore, Chiarelli. In addition, She said the bill risk of becoming another faulty process hidden under good intentions
.
Nancy Cairns. In addition, Stephanie Dobbs, two former employees of Rick Chiarelli spoke on Thursday during the public hearing on bill 9 lacks teeth, according bill 9.
Photo : Radio-Canada / Aya Dufour
The two women doubt that this bill in its current form could help them. Consequently, For a city councilor which committed a serious fault is dismissed. it would take three stages, the last being the unanimous vote of the municipal councilors (not affected by the allegations) in favor of the dismissal of their colleague.
The previous two stages are the investigation of a local integrity commissioner. a subsequent examination of the provincial commissioner for integrity. In both cases, the dismissal must be recommended.
The process would be practically impossible to implement
according to Ms. Cairns.
The members of the Council who work alongside the person accused of misconduct. who may be political allies or fear reprisals, must all vote to revoke it
she said during the public hearing on Thursday.
Instead of a unanimous vote, she proposed a non -political legal path for dismissal
.
Most of these cases end up being the subject of judicial control anyway
she explained.
What is written in this bill is redundant. exhausting and indicates to the survivors that the path to go simply is not worth it.
The Ontario government, led by Prime Minister Doug Ford, wants the new rules to be in force in time for the 2026 municipal elections.
Media coverage of misconduct Rick Chiarelli had aroused the indignation of the public. his colleagues around the table of the municipal council of Ottawa, who had also asked for his resignation. The main interested party had refused. but bill 9 lacks teeth, according he had not been able to escape a suspension of his salary for 90 days, the most severe sanction.
He retained his seat until the end of his mandate in 2022.
Bill 9 lacks teeth, according
A procedural shield
Joanne Chianello was a journalist for CBC when she has published reports on professional faults of Rick Chiarelli. She argued on Thursday that the advice [municipal] is not the appropriate body to make this kind of decision
.
She added: What is proposed here is not the way to justice. but a procedural shield that risks protecting even the worst offenders as long as they have only one ally within the Council
.
Other workers spoke. in particular Lisa Deacona bill 9 lacks teeth, according member of Leadership female Prescot-Russell, suggesting that a majority of two thirds of the council is sufficient to dismiss.
The president of the Ontario Municipalities Association. Robin Jonesargued that its organization would prefer that the power of dismissal will be entrusted to an independent judge.
Supports had been hung on a tree in front of the Ottawa City Hall following the dissemination of a CBC report according to bill 9 lacks teeth, according which the municipal councilor Rick Chiarelli had asked inappropriate questions of a sexual nature during an interview. (Archives photo)
Photo: Radio-chanada / Christian Milette
Preserve democratic responsibility
As a promoter of the bill. the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing, Rob Flackdefended the requirement of a vote unanimously.
The process describes the need for external influence while preserving democratic responsibility at the local level
he said on July 3. stressing that only the members of the Council who are not the subject of a complaint, who are not on approved leave and who are not in conflict of interest would be authorized to vote.
The Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing, Rob Flack. (Archives photo)
Photo: Canadian press / Coleton Coleton
Other people took advantage of the public hearing to express loud. clear that they did not support the objective of the bill.
We have elections to decide that represents us and it’s like that for a very long time. If a politician is unpopular. the voters believe that he does not serve them, they will not re -make it
pleaded Ryan Linkletter, who opposed the mechanism for the dismissal of elected officials provided for by the bill.
With information from bill 9 lacks teeth, according Campbell MacDiaridof News
Further reading: The bones found in Cascapédia-Saint-Jules are human – Worried about customs tariffs aimed at Canada, Wall Street is down – Prices: “Everyone is disappointed, but no one is surprised” – Canada needs an agency to manage UFO reports, reports – Sherbrookois conductor François Bernier would have made another victim.
