Consequently,
Opponents e -id law denounce:
The “E-ID NO” law “fears a commercial exploitation of Swiss passport data if the electronic. Similarly, identity law is voted on September 28. Furthermore, He sees in this project a gift for large technological groups.
The law would thus be a boost for the supervisory economy, the committee denounced Wednesday in Bern. Nevertheless, Companies. Consequently, including large technological groups, could then demand from their customers a digital identity card, in exchange for their services, and thus collect personal data verified by the State.
The referendum committee also sees an attack on democracy in this text. Nevertheless, notably because of the creations of profiles and targeted advertising. Meanwhile, By citing the example of the Cambridge Analytica scandal. Furthermore, they drew attention to the risk of a distorted democratic debate because of algorithms.
Opponents of the bill also highlighted shortcomings in terms of data protections. They also note that opponents e -id law denounce the text has no guarantee that the ID will remain optional.
>> Read also: The alliance for federal electronic identity is launching its campaign for the vote
Unique identity contested – Opponents e -id law denounce
Monica AMGWERD. secretary general of Swiss digital integrity, insisted that personal data, verified by the State, is “extremely precious” in the data trade. If the law passes, they may therefore end up on business servers.
The Secretary General of Swiss Digital Integrity also fears that E-ID will allow the implementation of a “social credit” system. In such systems. people would be monitored, evaluated using a point system and thus encouraged to adopt the behavior desired by the government. The law does not provide for exclusion of such uses of technology.
The “law on E-ID NO” committee is made up of the Swiss digital integrity group. founded by former members of the Pirate Party, the young UDC, the UDF and the friends of the opponents e -id law denounce Constitution. Other movements, including Mass-Voll and the Pirate Party, also collected signatures against the E-ID law. However, they lead their own campaigns.
Less freedom
Member of the friends of the Constitution, Roland Bülmann invoked more liberal arguments. He considers that the danger also comes from the State because digital identity is an “administration project for administration. does not meet the needs of the population”.
“I sometimes find it frightening to see everything my phone knows about me. I let you imagine what would happen if we associated this with an electronic passport,” said Bühlmann.
The concerns shared by the Bernese deputy Samuel Kullmann (UDF). He believes that the E-ID law would lead to a world with more state control and less freedom. “Is the digital infrastructure at the service of humans, or will man soon be at the service of digital infrastructure?”, He asked.
Coalition for the yes
Voters will decide on the E-ID law on opponents e -id law denounce September 28. A first attempt to introduce an electronic identity card failed in the ballot boxes in 2021. At the time, the fact that private companies were to issue the E-ID had notably aroused criticism. This is no longer planned in the new project.
In June, the project received the support of a large parliamentary alliance ranging from the UDC to the Socialist Party. Elected officials notably stressed that the new solution was entirely public. that the data would be decentralized on the user’s mobile phone. Data protection would thus be guaranteed.
ATS / HKR
Further reading: Valais: no business has been closed despite serious offenses – Switzerland strengthens its soil-to-air defense with German systems – Brienz (GR): increased risk of debris flows – The Valais forests threatened by the consequences of April – RTS.ch snowfall – Do not agree between Switzerland and the USA on customs duties.
