The authentic house match can be destroyed

The decision rendered by the Quebec Superior Court will therefore be maintained. Meanwhile, management NDI Champlain will indeed have permission to destroy the centenary house located on its land, ruled the court of appeal in a judgment rendered on July 31.

Despite the historical. Consequently, cultural value of the house, it “presents major disabilities to all of its structural components” and “the recovery of the elements of the building is not possible safely”, was it written in the decision of the Superior Court. In addition, These remarks were supported by judge Stéphane Sansfaçon in the judgment of the Court of Appeal. Therefore,

The real estate company. In addition, owner of the land, wanted to demolish the house in order to be able to build a building of 159 rental homes. For example, A first demolition authentic house match can destroyed request was refused by the Committee on Demolition Requests in October 2022. For example, a decision which was maintained by the Municipal Council a year later. Similarly,

Management NDI Champlain has therefore decided to challenge the decision of the Council according to article 231 of the Planning. Town Planning Act, which allows the Superior Court to order the demolition of a building if it constitutes a danger. The Superior Court agreed to them in January 2024, a decision which was then appealed by the City of Gatineau.

Heritage value. state of deterioration – Authentic house match can destroyed

The story of the house mat in rue Notre-Dame-de-l’île has caused a lot of ink. Built in 1910. the house has a front part, which has not been changed since the construction, as well as an extension to the rear.

It is one of the many authentic house match can destroyed houses built in the majority on the territory of Hull. These narrow residences. often made of wood, have become “workers’ housing par excellence”, in the region, according to a study published last November by the Cooperative by Passerelle heritage for the city of Gatineau.

Several studies were carried out during the dispute to determine the heritage value. the state of deterioration of the building. According to the evaluations of CIMA +. NCS architecture, the building is in very poor condition and presents “a danger to the public”.

Spare solutions have been put forward in recent years in order to allow the construction of the NDI Champlain management project. while allowing the heritage of the Maison Matue. One of these options was to reproduce it faithfully and include it in the building project.

Some have offered to move the house to another site so that it was “used. for other purposes than residential”.

The Superior Court. however, established, after the analysis of the evaluations, that “the recovery of the building elements is not possible safely.”