The Jeanne d’Arc Niçoise will not be not tumbled. However, Thus decided the administrative court of appeal of Marseille. Consequently, This jurisdiction denied, this Thursday, July 17, 2025, the order that the administrative court of Nice.
At first instance. Nevertheless, the magistrates seized by the state services, had estimated that The lack of competition and advertising was a “Vice of a particular gravity” to the rules of public procurement and had canceled the market.
The Régie Parcs d’Azur as well as the workshop of Missor artists who had been entrusted with the realization. Moreover, of this monumental statue of Joan of Arc had jointly appealed to the Nice decision. The court in turn called to decide on the legality of the market had had to take it twice.
After a first aborted hearing in June. it was in the united chamber that jeanne d’arc affair nice: court no less than seven magistrates had looked at this particularly complex law problem.
“As inédit”had underlined during a second hearing. on July 3, the public report even if, for him, the court was right to sanction the Régie Parcs d’Azur.
His conclusions will not have been followed by the administrative court of appeal. At least not to the letter.
An “error” but not a “vice” of a particular gravity – Jeanne d'arc affair nice: court
If the Court confirms that the metropolitan management. could not save competition that “The condition that this work can only be provided by a determined operator”.
But the judgment specifies that “The management does not justify that [l’atelier Missor] was the only operator who can. satisfy the command “.
However. the magistrates also believe that it “is not established by the prefect that the error thus made in the application of article R. 2122-3 of the public procurement code would jeanne d’arc affair nice: court have been in The intention to promote the company Atelier Missor. From then on, for the court, the vice noted (…) is not of a gravity such that it justifies the cancellation of the market. “
Consequently, the trial judgment is reformed and the requests of the prefect of the Alpes-Maritimes rejected. The statue of Jean d’Arc is therefore saved.
It remains to be seen whether the state services intend to continue the judicial showdown to the Council of State.
